The End of Analogue - Is analogue multitrack recording dead? (part 2)
I dont think anyone is in serious doubt anymore that digital recording is better than analogue. Some people will say that analogue has its own special sound which is certainly true. These people probably also prefer vinyl records to CD and black and white television to colour.
I dont think anyone is in serious doubt anymore that digital recording
is better than analogue. Some people will say that analogue has its own special
sound which is certainly true. These people probably also prefer vinyl records
to CD and black and white television to colour. I would say that while it would
be nice to have these old sounds available in an effects rack (along with the
gritty distortion of optical sound on film), it is not appropriate - unless
you specialise in the musical styles of a bygone era - to apply them to everything
you record. 16 bit digital audio is a much more transparent information channel,
even if its not perfect yet. By the way, if you want to see how bad some
digital convertors are, record a sine wave tone onto your DAT and slowly reduce
the level to zero. Now play the tape back, and as the tone diminishes, increase
the monitor level to compensate. If the convertors are good then you will hear
a noise building up which is smooth and even in character. On cheaper machines
the noise will be harsh and gritty - not very nice at all. If the sine wave
itself starts to become harsh then the convertors are not as linear as they
ought to be. Youll probably hate digital after you try this!
Even when working at its best, 16 bit recording is not always ideal. One day,
digital recording will be 24 bit and very close to being absolutely linear (free
of distortion within the 24 bit limit). When that day arrives well probably
rediscover analogue and apply all the techniques learnt along the way to create
an even greater argument! For now, 16 bit digital audio is considered perfectly
good enough for domestic stereo listening providing all the bits are used. But
16 bits are not quite good enough for mixing to stereo in the studio because
you have no margin of error - its virtually impossible to get full value
out of that very last bit and drive the signal all the way up to 1111111111111111
without going over the top at all. 16 bit multitrack is definitely not good
enough because each time you double the number of tracks you mix together the
noise goes up by a theoretical 3dB. This means that sixteen tracks of 16 bit
recording will mix together to give the equivalent of 14 bits, in the worst
case situation. The signal to noise ratio of the mix would in theory be 82dB
rather than the 96dB (in theory once again) of each individual track. So to
be compatible with 16 bit stereo standards, a sixteen track digital multitrack
machine should record to 18 bit resolution.
It should be evident that sound quality-wise, digital recording is not perfect.
But even so, I would still confirm my absolute certainty that its a damn
sight better than any current analogue format other than Dolby SR noise reduction
used on machinery of a full professional standard. This last option can give
16 bit digital a fright, but only at a very considerable cost. As I shall be
pointing out shortly, a digital multitrack recorder with A to D and D to A convertors
of reasonable quality such as the Alesis ADAT is easily superior in sound quality
to narrow gauge analogue machines such as the Fostex G and Tascam MSR models.
Its not the fault of the analogue machines or their designers, its
just the way things are.
The exciting sounds of The Phantom of the Opera (from 25 years ago!)
When it opened in 1986, The Phantom of the Opera wowed theater crowds with its exciting and novel electronic accompanying sounds. But two and a half decades later do these sounds still have the power to excite? Will your exciting sounds still be exciting in 2036? Read more...
The iPad - it's really quite mediocre
It was supposed to be a magical and revolutionary device. But now that it's here, it is plain that it really isn't anything special at all. Read more...
Q: Why is one channel always higher in level than the other?
A RecordProducer.com reader finds himself always with the left meter showing higher levels than the right. Why is this? Read more...
Build a working turntable from CARDBOARD, courtesy of Kid Koala
Kid Koala's new CD, 12 bit Blues, comes with a cardboard turntable that you can build yourself, plus a flexidisc to play on it. Want one? You really should! Read more...
The best tape recorder in the world is for sale!
Grab yourself a piece of audio history that still has the power to deliver the goods. It's on eBay right now! Read more...
"Just a Riddle" by Tony Danes Higgnbe project
I'm working with sonar producer 7. I plan on building a new machine this summer and upgrading to the new sonar.... Read more...
Can you get good people to work with you?
It's all very well being very good at what you do. But will the people you work with have an influence on the success of your career? Read more...
Mixing: Where to start? - The drum kit?
When a multitrack session might contain twenty or thirty audio tracks or more, it might be difficult to know where to begin mixing. But over the course of the next few days, Audio Masterclass and RecordProducer.com will provide several 'get you started' options. Read more...
An inside view of the weirdest recording session ever, at the BBC!
Take a 300-year old bass line, a cello player with just seven days' experience, and some highly uncool-looking musicians... and make a recording that is really top of the pops for weird! Read more...
Will the iPad change the way you make music?
Apple's launch of the iPad has created a whole new segment in computing. Should musicians rejoice? Or be very afraid? Read more...
How to use as many plug-ins as you like
You are running tons of plug-ins and your computer is running out of steam. How can you lighten the load AND use as many plug-ins as you like? Read more...
Q: David Mellor, do you ever do any live training?
I would like to know if Audio Masterclass Course Director David Mellor ever does any live training, or is Audio Masterclass purely distance learning? Read more...
What is your main concern if your interest is voice over?
So you're setting yourself up in the voice over business. What should you think about before anything else? Read more...
Windows 8 brings performance improvements to Sonar
Lower latency, better CPU load balancing, reduced memory usage, better disk performance... Something to look forward to? Read more...
Help! I have too much equipment. What can I do?
A Record-Producer.com visitor complains that he has too much equipment and wants to get rid of half of it. Trouble is - he doesn't know which half... Read more...
To eliminate feedback is it good to reduce the gain and raise the fader? (Part 1)
An RP reader has feedback problems. But will clever manipulation of the gain control and fader provide the cure? In Part 1 of a two-part article, we explore the concept of loop gain. Read more...
Does your studio look like a studio, or just another room?
What is it about your studio that makes it look and feel like a recording studio, and a nice place to work? Or is it just another room in your house? Read more...
Mixing: Where to start? - Just throw the faders up at random!?
You may be an expert mix engineer, but even the best mix engineers can't imagine all of the possibilities contained within a multitrack recording. Random chance may offer better solutions than ever could be planned. Read more...
Parallel compression: Finding excitement in the lower levels
The ear and brain pay much more attention to high-level sounds than low. So if you can bring up the low levels you might find a new source of excitement in your audio. Read more...
What is production? Part 1: A&R
If you spend a lot of time reading and viewing videos about professional audio on the Internet, then you could easily get the idea that production is all about having the right equipment and software, particularly plug-ins. It is very true that getting the right sound is an important part of production, but there's a lot more to it than that. In this series, I will take a look at the five major components of production. A&R, arrangement, recording, mixing and mastering. Read more...