I came across this photo in an advert for DPA microphones. Specifically these are the DPA 4061 microphones, which are available with the SMK4061 stereo microphone kit, which comprises a range of mounting accessories.
Now I'm not saying these are bad mics. I've heard DPA microphones and they are remarkably faithful to the sound source. It's just the way these mics are used I have issue with.
Firstly, have you ever put your head inside a piano? Go on, try it. I'll play bars 105 to 119 of Liszt's Piano Sonata in B minor and see how you feel after that! 'Deaf' will be one word for it.
No, these microphones are in completely the wrong place to capture the natural sound of the piano.
Also, you can see that each mic is probably around 10 cm from the nearest string. That will make it about 60 cm or so from the furthest string. This will create a massive difference in loudness. So the loudness will vary according to which notes are played.
Now if you have a special purpose in mind, and this sound suits what you want - wrong though it is - then fine. Recording is all about creativity. I have no problem with that.
But my suspicion is that the reason these mics are inside the piano is because they are being used for a TV broadcast. And the director has demanded that the mics are not visible.
So the piano looks good - no nasty microphones surrounding it.
It just doesn't sound good.
But there is worse. What if, horror of horrors...?
The sound engineer himself or herself chose to use the mics like this because it's more convenient than using stands!
OK, there's one excuse. If the piano is to be moved, the mics will move with the piano. During a live show that might be a worthwhile convenience.
But just to save setting up a couple of stands. No, no, no.
Sound engineers all want to achieve the best sound possible. Well nearly all. And sometimes we have to stand up to people that would make us compromise.
Next time, use the biggest mics you can find, on the chunkiest stands. Position them to perfection and get exactly the sound you want, without compromise.
“It isn't about equipment and software -
To achieve success in music, you don't necessarily have to be able to sing all that well. Here's proof... Read more...
So you record using virtual instruments. Can you really call yourself a producer? Read more...
I have a recording done in a very large hall and it has a lot of reverb on it. How do I get rid of the reverb or reduce it? Read more...
A RecordProducer.com reader has a song that is too long. How can he edit it so that it is shorter? Read more...
A RecordProducer.com reader has an expensive microphone preamplifier. But he worries that all is lost when he connects it to the preamp of his audio interface. Read more...
In theory, digital audio is more accurate than vinyl records. But in many cases you will hear the artist's and producer's intentions much more accurately on vinyl than you will on CD or download. Read more...
We have always thought of working with sound as the most fun you can have without laughing. Not for everyone by the look of things... Read more...
The power rating of a loudspeaker might be 500 watts; it might be 2000 watts. But how much power can it truly handle? Read more...
A wrong note that has resonated for more than half a century is fixed - without the aid of a time machine. Read more...
What makes a hit record? Sometimes it's the song, sometimes it's the sound. But who decides whether a certain 'sound' will sell? Read more...
It's all very well being very good at what you do. But will the people you work with have an influence on the success of your career? Read more...
Grab yourself a piece of audio history that still has the power to deliver the goods. It's on eBay right now! Read more...
Although modern loudspeakers are capable of reproducing the sound of virtually any instrument, somehow they seem to sound more like a loudspeaker than the instrument itself. Why is this so? Is there such a thing as a loudspeaker that actually doesn't sound like a speaker? Read more...
Using microphones in a stereo pair always raises a good question - are you SURE they sound right? Read more...
When stereo sounds so much better and more lifelike than mono, why would you ever want to record a vocal with a single mic? Read more...
What product doesn't exist today that we could really make use of in the studio? A remote controlled microphone stand of course! Read more...
The Auto-Tune debate is unlikely to go away. Those who can, sing. Those who can't use Auto-Tune. Read more...
You'll never get a good recording of a drum set if the cymbals sound bad. But how you be sure to get a perfect cymbal sound every time? Read more...
An RP reader successfully lands an internship in a major recording studio. But the kind of work he is asked to do isn't quite what he expected... Read more...
Will Loomis thinks that Jessie J's song 'Domino' is a ripoff of his song 'Bright Red Chords', allegedly. But how many notes does it take to be scoundrel in the music business? Read more...
Getting the music done is one thing, getting the artwork finished is another. But what about all the other information a CD needs?
Classical music just needs to be recorded, doesn't it? Well in some cases it really can be produced.
Can an $89 pair of monitors really be an effective tool in the recording studio? Or are they only good for 'media creation?
A wrong note that has resonated for more than half a century is fixed - without the aid of a time machine.
An RP reader finds that a certain combination of microphone and preamp works much better than he expected...
Anyone with a home recording studio now has the means to create a hit. So why haven't you yet?
What sounds good to the electric guitar player doesn't necessarily sound good to the audience. A live sound engineer explains...
So you're setting yourself up in the voice over business. What should you think about before anything else?
Amazingly, the answer to this question is - almost - yes!
If you're miking one of the finest violinists in the world, should you point the mic at the double bass instead?
An RP reader fears losing cabinet resonances if the backline of his band is miked up through the PA. But perhaps it is innovation in live sound that has been lost over the years.
Any theatre would have tielines from the stage to the sound control booth. But from one side of the booth's window to the other?
A major producer has 'stolen' a song from a pair of unknowns. A crime, or normal everyday life in the music business?
AKG makes some of the best mics in the world. AKG also makes a USB mic. A great USB mic?
Two singers, one microphone. Could it cause an Internet sensation?
If a tree falls in the woods, does it make a sound (if no-one is around to hear it?) If you can't hear hum, then is there no hum?
Are you planning on getting your tracks mastered? Then the first rule of preparation is not to master the tracks yourself.
You can get a plug-in to emulate virtually any analog audio process these days. But what about hum? Where's the plug-in for that?
Take a 300-year old bass line, a cello player with just seven days' experience, and some highly uncool-looking musicians... and make a recording that is really top of the pops for weird!
Sometimes unusual microphone placements can capture an interesting sound. In this instance, the sound is completely wrong.